Teachers and Classmates Express Outrage at Arrest of Girl, 16, as a
By NINA BERNSTEIN
Published: April 9, 2005
register to view original article)
At Heritage High School in East Harlem, where the student idiom is hip-hop
and salsa, the 16-year-old Guinean girl stood out, but not just because she
wore Islamic dress. She was so well liked that when she ran for student body
president, she came in second to one of her best friends - the Christian
daughter of the president of the parent-teacher association, Deleen P. Carr.
Now Ms. Carr, a speech pathologist who calls herself "a typical American
citizen," is as outraged as the girl's teachers and classmates, who have
learned that the girl and another 16-year-old are being called would-be
suicide bombers and are being held in an immigration detention center in
"They have painted this picture of her as this person that is trying to
destroy our way of life, and I know in my heart of hearts that this is
bogus," said Ms. Carr, who welcomed the Guinean girl to her house daily and
knows her family well. "I feel like, how dare they? She's a minor, and even
if she's not a citizen, she has rights as a human being."
According to a government document provided to The New York Times by a
federal official earlier this week, the Federal Bureau of Investigation has
asserted that both girls are "an imminent threat to the security of the
United States based on evidence that they plan to be suicide bombers." No
evidence was cited, and federal officials will not comment on the case.
Its mysteries deepened as teachers and neighbors gave details of the Guinean
girl's life, like the jeans she wore under her Muslim garb, her lively
classroom curiosity about topics like Judaism and art and her after-school
care for four younger siblings while her parents, illegal immigrants who
have lived in the United States since 1990, eked out a living.
"I just can't fathom this," said her art teacher, Kimberly Lane, who has
repeatedly called the youth detention center but like Ms. Carr was not
allowed to speak to the girl, who has no lawyer. Among the unanswered
questions they raised was why, if she was really a suspect, no F.B.I. agent
had shown up to search her school locker or question her classmates, who
sent her letters of support.
"This is a girl who's been in this country since she was 2 years old," Ms.
Lane said. "She's just a regular teenager - like, two weeks ago her biggest
worry was whether she'd done her homework or studied for a science test."
Until now, attention has focused on the other 16-year-old, a Bangladeshi
girl reared in Queens who could not deal with the hurly-burly of her West
Side high school and withdrew into home schooling. Yesterday, on a motion of
the government, an immigration judge closed the Bangladeshi girl's bond
hearing to the public and adjourned it to next Thursday, said Troy Mattes, a
lawyer who is taking over the case but has yet to meet her.
By the Bangladeshi girl's account, reported by her mother, the girls did not
meet until March 24, after their separate arrests in early-morning raids on
immigration charges against their parents. Both grew up in Islamic families.
But while the Bangladeshi girl had grown increasingly pious, and
uncomfortable in the urban culture of the High School of Environmental
Studies on West 56th Street, the Guinean girl, a 10th grader, embraced every
aspect of Heritage High, at 106th Street and Lexington Avenue, her teachers
"She is, yes, an orthodox Muslim, but completely integrated into this
school," said Jessica Siegel, her English teacher in a class in which topics
like teenage pregnancy and world politics were discussed. Ms. Siegel was
profiled in the book "Small Victories," by Samuel G. Freedman, as an
unsentimental, but fiercely committed teacher who provoked and delighted her
"She's a wonderful, wonderful girl," Ms. Siegel said. "She's about the last
person anyone could imagine being a suicide bomber."
The English teacher's most vivid recollection was of a day two months ago
when she heard a kind of roar in the hallway of the school, which is full of
colorful student collages and life-size sculptures in papier-mâché. The
teenager had stopped wearing her veil, and she beamed as her fellow
students, seeing her face for the first time, cheered.
After the class read "Night," the Holocaust memoir by Elie Wiesel, the girl
wrote a paper about genocide in the Sudan, she recalled. But she was so
excited about a field trip to see Christo's "Gates" in Central Park, Ms.
Siegel said, that she skipped an appointment at immigration - a teenage
impulse the teacher now worries might have set off problems with federal
authorities. Her father is now in immigration jail facing deportation.
At Woodrow Wilson Houses a few blocks from the school, a sticker on the
family's apartment door reads, "Allah is our protector." Yesterday no one
was home, but across the hall, Christine Anderson, a neighbor, shook her
head in disbelief when she learned why she had not seen the girl or her
father in recent weeks.
"Why would they take the lady's daughter?" she asked. "They're nice people,
and hard-working people. I've been here four years. I know she's not a
Ms. Lane, the art teacher, said that when Heritage High first learned that
immigration agents had picked up the girl, one of her best friends asked if
someone from the school might have denounced her as an illegal immigrant. "I
remember telling her the government doesn't go after 16-year-old girls," Ms.
Lane said. "And in the last few days, I'm wrestling with the fact that, yes,